Backyard Chickens: Free Range vs. Enclosed Run

It’s hard to believe it’s been almost two years since we acquired our first set of cute little fluffy cheeps and set off to build a chicken coop that ended up costing us an arm and a leg (how many eggs do we have to sell again?) and a lot of lessons learned.

Since then we’ve raised three batches of chicks, built them a chicken swing to keep them entertained, created grazing boxes so they could have fresh greens, built an enclosed chicken run made out of pallets to give them more space, enjoyed the excitement of the “first egg” many times, and a whole lot more. We’ve learned the best way not to have a brooder box, what to look for when buying chicks, and how quickly they can become beloved pets (even if that was not the intention).

Up until about 9 months ago, all of our chickens stayed in our enclosed run and palleted area.

We never had any issues of them flying over our pallet area because the enclosed run was all they knew. That is, until my husband decided to let them out in the yard for the first time.

I would be lying if I said it wasn’t awesome to see them so happy scratching around in the dirt, clucking, running across the yard. Having them out in the yard provided us with cheap entertainment and made our hearts full to see them doing their chicken thing (and not having to worry about keeping up the grazing boxes or growing sprouts as treats for them).

I mean seriously, what’s better than watching your kid run around the yard with a flock of chickens chasing after him?

Things were going great until the ring leader of our youngest flock decided she was going to break all the rules and fly up to the top of the pallet area. One by one, her patrons followed her and started a whole new set of problems. Isn’t it funny how it only takes ONE chicken (or person) to go against the grain and then the others start following, creating problems for everyone else?

Every time I would let them out in the pallet area and turn my back to head into the house, that damn ring leader would jump up onto the top of the pallet, and again, her three bandit sisters would hop up and they’d all fly down into the garden bed.


The ring leader was a rebel (pictured below). That is for sure. Unfortunately (sorta), she got attacked by something and was completely eaten when we forgot to close them up for the night. I would by lying if I said I wasn’t kind of glad. She created some bad habits in the group and I was growing tired of it.


If you have chickens in an enclosed run and are considering free-ranging them in your yard, or if you are about to get chicks and are wondering if free-ranging them is what you’ll do, consider these pros and cons I have personally experienced.

Pros of Free-Ranging Backyard Chickens

  • Fresh grass and bugs means a lower feed bill (and insect control!)
  • It also means healthier, happier chickens (when they were cooped up and we had really bad weather for weeks on end, one of our chickens developed an egg-eating habit. Once we let them out in the yard, the egg-eating stopped)
  • Less maintenance when it comes to pulling weeds, buying old lettuce, and maintaining the grazing boxes to feed them fresh greens
  • Cheap entertainment (see video above)
  • You can make slow-mo videos of your chickens chasing after your kid
  • Natural fertilizer in the yard

Cons of Free-Ranging Backyard Chickens

  • Chicken poop. All. Over. The. Yard.
  • They have tasted freedom so now every time you open up the door to the enclosed run, they turn into cockroaches and try to get out of the run
  • They destroy everything; including the freshly planted flower beds and your garden you worked so hard on. Now you have to figure out a way to chicken-proof your garden, aka time and money.
  • If you have predators that can get to your chickens, you’ll have to supervise them while they’re out in the yard.

In the end it really depends on your personal situation, how many chickens you intend on keeping, and how “hands on” you want to be. For us, the pros outweigh the cons, but it is a little annoying that we’re going to have to reconfigure our garden area so the chickens don’t destroy it.

We’re also considering buying a light weight fencing system to keep the chickens to one part of the yard when they’re out instead of them being able to go wherever they want. Doing this will eliminate poop being everywhere.

More Posts You Might Like:

  1. How to Tell When Your Chicken Will Start Laying (Video)
  2. Why I Don’t Refrigerate My Backyard Eggs
  3. You Might Be a Crazy Chicken Lady If…
  4. Growing Sprouts as Treats for Chickens
  5. The Reality of Owning Chickens
  6. Chicken Coop Confessions

Similar Posts


  1. I keep my chickens in a large enclosed area that has 6′ tall fences. During the winter, when nothing much was growing in the garden, I allowed them out for most of the day. Even though I live in the middle of the city, I did have a hawk try to attack one day. Luckily, all of the chickens ran for cover & the dogs were able to chase away the hawk. Now that springtime is here, and lots of new veggies plants are in the garden, I can’t let them out, even with supervision. Like you, one decided to fly over the fence. And the others soon followed. I remembered a trick I read about somewhere: string along the top of the fences. Using some scrap wood, I heightened the fence posts about 1 foot. I then ran 2 rows of string along the top of the fence. This made it unstable for them to land on. Since then – no more chicken escapees!!.

    And you are so right about poop everywhere!! You’d think with all the grass, they’d stay off the patio & the back porch, but no – that’s where most of the poop lands. I used to love walking barefoot in the garden. Now I definitely keep an old pair of shoes by the back door & slip into them every time I go outdoors.

  2. My chickens are free range, all the time from spring to winter! Very large area for them to run, and some places fence is only 2 ft high, and they never try to jump on, or over? I guess they know their area. Every ,morning they r waiting in run at the door to get out with noise. I don’t have problem with poop, some how large area you can’t even find? The only thing I did, protected all my flowers and vegetable with plastic fencing. I really enjoy their happy time out of run! If some big bird fly over my beautiful rooster is in action ! Oh, he is better then dog!

  3. I would love to read and see about your light weight fencing system, if you ever put one up. We have 10 acres and are set far back on it, but unfortantely, so is our neighbor on the next road over. His property butts up to ours. He has always enjoyed our ladies. He began feeding the wildlife which is what initially ignited the girls curiosity to pass through our small stretch of wood to his yard. Then he purposely began feeding them on top of it all. Do you blame them with all that yumminess? Well, this year, he put down two different colored bark (who does that? 😂) and the girls are no longer allowed over as they began to mix colors! We made their run larger, but I so badly want to put up some sort of makeshift fence in order to let them free range on their own without worrying they high tailed it to where they feel the “grass is greener”. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *